19.11.2026

PIS/COFINS on Net-Metered Energy: A Charge Without Legal Grounds

Shared generation arrangements — consortiums, cooperatives and associations linked to remote power plants, usually solar — have grown significantly in Brazil and become one of the main paths to democratizing access to clean energy. Yet this model conceals a tax problem that receives little attention and has been quietly costing participants and investors money, with no clear legal basis.

The core issue is straightforward: some consumers taking part in these arrangements end up paying PIS and COFINS (federal social contribution taxes) on energy that the arrangement itself generates and that the utility merely offsets on the bill — energy on which the utility earns no real revenue. When the consumer units within the same arrangement belong to different account holders, some utilities apply these taxes to the full recorded consumption, rather than to the net amount left after the offset.

The practical effect can be severe. In a simple example, with 100 kWh consumed and 70 kWh offset through shared generation, the tax base can end up more than three times larger than the energy actually billed — and this distortion repeats every single month, invoice after invoice.

From a legal standpoint, this charge lacks support in tax law, in the regulatory framework for distributed generation, and in the sector’s own technical understanding of how energy offsetting works. That is exactly why it can and should be challenged, with a claim for reimbursement of amounts improperly paid.

Brazil’s federal tax authority, through Binding Ruling (Solução de Consulta Cosit) No. 168/2026, has already recognized a zero tax rate in one specific scenario: when ownership of the energy is transferred to the consumer-generator. The problem is that this ruling does not cover most shared-generation arrangements currently in operation, where each participant remains the holder of their own consumer unit.

There is also a time pressure element. PIS and COFINS will be phased out in January 2027, replaced by the CBS under Brazil’s tax reform. The right to recover amounts improperly paid remains valid for up to five years — but every month of inaction reduces the amount that can still be recovered. After the reform, the specific benefit discussed here will also disappear, and the regulations for the new CBS and IBS taxes tend to limit the exclusion of offset energy to shared-generation arrangements, which should spark new debates starting in 2027.

For plant managers and owners, this improper charge reduces the discount perceived by participants, pressures margins, and affects investor returns — adding to other well-known challenges in the sector, such as delinquency and the cost of capital.

The recommended first step is to audit utility bills to confirm the charge and quantify the amount involved, stop the improper payment going forward, and pursue reimbursement with the appropriate monetary correction.

This content was originally developed and published by Canal Solar, authored by Einar Tribuci. Read the original publication on Canal Solar.

Authors:

  • EINAR TRIBUCI
Contact us

Related

Tribuci Fonseca Advogados

© 2026 Tribuci e Fonseca - All rights reserved.

LETS MARKETING